1 of 7-part thought leadership series: Protecting and Sustaining Your Organisation Through Ethical Decision-Making

In the contemporary business environment, characterized by rapid change and intense scrutiny, the importance of ethical decision-making cannot be overstated. Ethical considerations are no longer peripheral concerns but central to organisational strategy and sustainability. The foundation of this ethical landscape is built on decisions that resonate with the organisation’s core values, shaping its culture, brand reputation, and stakeholder trust.

The Imperative of Ethical Decision-Making

The decisions an organisation makes underpin its relationship with employees, customers, investors, and the wider community. Ethical decision-making fosters a trustworthy environment, mitigating risks, and fostering long-term success. It’s the bedrock for compliance with regulatory standards and for driving corporate social responsibility. Unethical decisions, on the other hand, can lead to scandals, financial losses, legal ramifications, and irreparable damage to an organisation’s reputation.

Robert S. Hartman’s 3 Dimensions of Value

The framework proposed by Robert S. Hartman provides a nuanced approach to understanding ethics in the organisational context, offering three dimensions of value: Intrinsic, Extrinsic, and Systemic.

1. Intrinsic Value: This dimension is about recognizing the inherent worth of people within the organisation. It emphasises empathy, respect, and the treatment of stakeholders as ends in themselves. Intrinsic value is the humanistic thread in the fabric of organisational culture, ensuring that policies and actions reflect a genuine regard for people’s rights and dignity.
2. Extrinsic Value: Extrinsic value pertains to the measurable aspects of an organisation’s decisions and actions—profitability, operational efficiency, market share, and product quality. It is the dimension that most clearly aligns with the traditional business metrics of success.
3. Systemic Value: The third dimension focuses on the conceptual frameworks and systems that underlie an organisation’s functioning—its policies, procedures, rules, and standards. Systemic value stresses the importance of consistency, stability, and adherence to the collective ‘shoulds’ and ‘oughts’ that guide organisational behaviour.

Relevance to Organisational Ethics

The interplay of these dimensions shapes an organisation’s ethical compass:

Intrinsic values ensure that the organisation does not reduce stakeholders to mere tools for profitability.

Extrinsic values drive the organisation towards achieving its performance goals without compromising on ethics.

Systemic values bind the organisation to operate within a framework of legal and moral standards, fostering a sense of order and predictability.

Organisations that effectively integrate these three dimensions of value can navigate the complexities of ethical decision-making with clarity and integrity. For example, when faced with a decision about outsourcing, an organisation with a strong ethical compass will consider the impact on its employees (intrinsic value), assess the business benefits and costs (extrinsic value), and ensure the decision aligns with its policies and societal norms (systemic value).

The Way Forward

As we explore this series, we will delve deeper into each dimension’s role in various organisational scenarios and provide insights into balancing these values to safeguard and enhance the organisation’s ethical standing.

In conclusion, Hartman’s 3 Dimensions of Value offer a holistic lens through which organisations can examine and refine their decision-making processes. By fostering an environment where these values are balanced and integrated, organisations can protect and sustain their operations, ensuring that they do not just survive but thrive in today’s challenging business climate.

Stay tuned for the next article in this series, where we will analyse real-world cases through the lens of Hartman’s dimensions, providing a clearer view of the pitfalls and potentials in organisational ethics.

🚀 Embark on this journey of growth and ethical business practices. Your organisation’s future is at stake.

👉 Take the quiz now: [https://goodculture.scoreapp.com]

#EthicalLeadership #BusinessIntegrity #OrganisationalHealth #GoodCulture #ethics